If Mitch McConnell (or, say, Judd Gregg) were a Mensch…

…pigs would fly, I know, but if McConnell had any sense of decency he would do the following:

Vote for the stimulus package in the Senate.

Why?  So that his colleague, Sherrod Brown, would not have to leave his mother’s wake (say that again, in all caps:  HIS MOTHER’S WAKE) in Ohio, fly to DC, cast his vote, and then fly back to Ohio in time for his mother’s funeral (say that again, in all caps:  HIS MOTHER’S FUNERAL) tomorrow.

I mean, there is no doubt that the bill will pass.  There is no question that Brown’s vote will be the needed 60th to ensure passage.  The only other option, the only other vote to provide the margin of those who voted at the last, procedural hurdle is Ted Kennedy, and he’s dealing with brain cancer (caps again:  BRAIN CANCER), so it falls to Brown, trying to bury his mother, or some one Republican with a sense of decency sufficiently developed to switch his or her vote in Brown’s stead.

And what gravels me is that there would be no political price to be paid for such a switch — in fact, it would have only benefits for the brave senator to do so, and for his or her party.  It could be made clear that this is purely  a gesture, not of bipartisanship, but of sympathy and support for a co-worker dealing with a terribly rough time.

No one would accuse McConnell of betraying his principles (he has some-?-ed.) (shhh–tl) were he to so vote.  He could state very clearly what he was doing and why, (and send some sympathy Brown’s way).  He could be seen, for just a moment, as human being rather than a partisan hack.  Nothing but good could acrue to him here.

And I can’t believe there would be any electoral fall out that would follow what would be clearly understood by all as a classy gesture.  McConnell — or Gregg, or any of a number of Republicans of impeccable (sic) right wing ideological pedigree  — would be able to demonstrate a kind of reasonableness that the rest of their recent actions hide pretty well.

Even better:  they would be praised for the kind of gesture that the GOP has found it impossible to make in response to what polls show is a pretty effective campaign to suggest that they are refusing the proffered hand of a very popular president.

Plus, of course, its just the right thing to do, the sort of care you take for those with whom you work — even the ones with whom you disagree, who you may in fact dislike — just because it makes the world a slightly better place in a way that costs nothing.  Your mama told you to do such things; I and my wife work on my eight year old all the time to get him to internalize the notion that kindness is the default option in his dealings with the world.

Is this so hard to get?  To do?  If you are a Senate Republican, I guess so.

I can’t even get angry about this one.  It’s just sad.  These are damaged people.

Update: Hello to all dropping in from Balloon Juice — and thanks much to John Cole for the connection made.

Update 2: And to all of you dropping in from Grasping Reality… my thanks as well to Brad Delong for his notice of this quantum of rage.

Image:  Pawel Andrejewitsch Fedotow, “Funeral Clothing,” 1851.

Explore posts in the same categories: Republican follies, Republican knavery, Stupidity

10 Comments on “If Mitch McConnell (or, say, Judd Gregg) were a Mensch…”


  1. […] Here is something to think about: […]

  2. AJS Says:

    Why not Voinovich? It would only be an upside for him in Ohio.

    Monsters


  3. […] Minority Leader Mitch McConnell has the chance to show some real leadership and change his vote to an ‘Aye’ for the passage of the bill. Why? So that his colleague, Sherrod Brown, would not have to leave his […]

  4. MoeLarryAndJesus Says:

    There are very few Republicans left. It’s now the Repiglican Party. These people have been cheerleaders for murder and torture and theft for so long that they’re no longer capable of simple human decency.

  5. lilysmom Says:

    I had the same thought. Thank you for the post.

    It just goes to show that it is beyond them to be compassionate or have empathy. Now we know how they came up with their economic and security policies. They have no human soul.

    Somehow, after all that I have observed over the last almost fifty years, this is not a surprise.

  6. KCinDC Says:

    Suppose McConnell had called Brown up and said he’d vote for the bill. What about the past several years would make Brown or the other Democrats think they could trust a Republican to follow through on the promise?

  7. Theo Says:

    I wouldn’t trust any of the regpus as far as I could kick their bloated behinds

  8. save_the_rustbelt Says:

    The House vote was rushed so Nancy Pelosi would not miss her flight for a junket to Rome.

    The Senate was rushed so Senators would not miss their junket and vacation plans.

    Otherwise the Senate vote could easily have been taken on Monday.

    This bill was so critical the democratic process was largely bypassed to protect the junket plans of Democrats.

    But it was Mitch McConnell’s fault!

  9. nearlynormalized Says:

    The Republicans are where they want to be, on the defensive with nothing positive to say. Gregg is a hateful homophobic Yankee.


  10. […] Polarized Congress…ha There’s a large segment of literature in the political science community that talks about how polarized or non-polarized Congress is based on Roll Call votes. It’s all rather complicated, though leads to some impressive pictures and ideas. However I’ve never been fully satisfied with it because it misses some of the human element. Such as no Republican Senator having the decency to vote yes on the stimulus for Sherrod Brown. […]


Leave a comment