Posted tagged ‘mental illness’

Talking the Mental Illness Talk–OK. Walking the Walk?…

June 10, 2008

…Not so much, according to Michelle S.

Responding to my recent post on the Iraq War suicides and what they can tell us about the question of brains-and-minds, one of my favorite commenters (and a former student, much admired and much missed) weighs in from a position of much greater knowledge than I possess on issues of brains and mental illness. Michelle knows what she’s talking about and says it better than I could — so here is what she has to say:

_______________________________

I would love to think that some hope is justified here. Unfortunately, I don’t think that’s the case.

While it’s a major development (no pun intended) that the military is finally starting to take PTSD and other brain-related maladies seriously, I don’t think they’re anywhere near the level of understanding or action that is necessary to make any real progress. It’s one thing to admit that something exists–or at least sort of admit that it exists–but another to really do something about it. Admittedly, some of the military leaders seem to be trying. On the other hand, a lot of soldiers are still afraid to admit that they might be suffering from a mental illness.

Hell, plain old civilians are afraid to admit it, and for good reason in some cases, I might add. Stigma is far from gone in the US. As a country we offer sympathy and support for anyone suffering from an illness of the heart, the lungs, the kidneys, whatever, but the brain is still different to us somehow. We manage to forget that it is still an organ, albeit a really darned complicated one.

Then there’s the problem of mental illness in general–in fact, nearly any brain-related problem–being grossly misunderstood. I actually had a young mother say to me once, in regard to her two year old, “He’s so moody! I’m just terrified that he might be bipolar!” Dear, your child is not bipolar. He’s two. His “mental illness” is that he is a two year old. (And, I’m sure, by the time he’s five she’ll have him on ritalin–but NO ONE wants me to get started down that road.)

The public needs good, solid information about what mental illness is. The MSM has yet to provide that, in my opinion. Meanwhile, schizophrenics in particular continue to be demonized, even while they’re forced to live in a society that only treats mental illness as an afterthought. Have you heard even one Presidential candidate address the near-crisis that is geriatric mental health in the US? Ok, I’m preaching on a topic that is dear to my heart here, I know, but come ON–experts in that field are shouting at the top of their lungs about this problem. They have been for years. Why is no one listening? Why is insurance coverage for mental health such a joke?

Perhaps things are starting to improve. Perhaps the brain as a whole, with all of its complex subtleties, capabilities and limitations, will get the attention it needs and deserves. I hope that your hope is justified. But I think (and therefore I am–maybe) we’re a long way off.

——————————

Image:  Francisco de Goya, detail from No. 62 in the series Los Caprichos, 1799. Source:  Wikimedia Commons.