Stupid Idea For Readers To Destroy

David Anderson’s post at Balloon-Juice got me thinking on single payer vs. universal coverage — I’m with David (and Elie). Don’t care how we get to health care for all Americans, as long as we get there.

So here’s my stupid idea: a move in stages.*

Stage one: Medicare For All Kids.  Same program, just for every kid up to the age of 18–or 26, to match current ACA practice.

The reasoning in my wholly non-expert addled brain being twofold: first, kids are, as a group, cheap to cover, so the financial lift here is presumably manageable.  Second: this has an aspirational frame that can be used to persuade.  I don’t know about you, but I’ll take (I took) risks on my own behalf I would never have done had I my son to keep safe when I started my own small business.  I don’t know how many people have deferred or abandoned dreams because they couldn’t go insurance-naked for their kids.

That’s anecdata, but David Leonhardt made much the same argument way back in 2010 in defense of the bill that became Obamacare. Medicare For All Kids, presented as a way to unleash Americans’ entrpreneurial spirit, would be a proposition on which I think Democrats could go to town.

The next stage is to take the step that didn’t find our David’s 218-51-5 support in the last go-round:  Medicare (buy-in?) For All Over 55.  This is a form of public option, and it would expand the single-payer approach to more and more of those either utterly unable to take on health risk themselves (kids, the post-work elderly) and those whose age-adjusted risk is growing to the point where it threatens to become unmanageable.   Again, this would require persuasion, but the idea that older but not old folks who might face, say, a 2008-like crisis of employment should find a ready avenue to coverage is, again, a case that can be made (by a better political rhetorician than me).

That leaves 27-55 year olds on their own — or rather, within the existing Obamacare/expanded Medicaid universe.  But it establishes a template for a single payer form of coverage without requiring a wholesale change over of a system with tons of interested parties and rent-seekers eager to defend their turf.

So — to steal Ta-Nehisi Coates’ old line: talk to me like I’m stupid.

What’s wrong with a crabwise walk towards increasingly universal health care, along these lines or better ones? For both politics and policy, what would be wrong w. introducing, say a Medicare For All  Kids bill in this Congress, just to get that ball rolling?

David? Anybody?

*”We shall fight in France, we shall fight on the seas and oceans, we shall fight with growing confidence and growing strength in the air, we shall defend our island, whatever the cost may be. We shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender.”

Image: Edvard Munch, The Sick Child, 1907

Explore posts in the same categories: Health Care, Uncategorized


You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

3 Comments on “Stupid Idea For Readers To Destroy”

  1. kaleberg Says:

    There’s nothing wrong with the approach in principle, but it creates an awful lot of different classes of insured people. Let’s suppose we allow a subsidized Medicare buy in at 55. You would imagine that this would link everyone over 55 in solidarity to preserve and extend Medicare, but it would be just as likely as we find over 65 Medicare people resenting the new 55-65 group. After all, this group has BUY Medicare. They haven’t really earned it the way true over 65 Medicare people have. Resentment is a powerful force, especially since people tend to resent people who have less than they have rather those who have more.

    BTW That Munch picture, The SIck Child, was on the cover a pretty good book about tuberculosis, The White Death. Our car got a flat in Rochester, MN, so we spent a night in town and went to the Barnes & Noble in the downtown maze after dinner. It’s a company town, so they had a great medical book collection, so I wound up learning something of the history of tuberculosis. Munch’s older sister died of the disease, and you can tell from the painting that he was very much affected by this.

  2. H-Bob Says:

    Another stage would be to provide lifetime medical care for veterans (not just for service-related ailments), which should be politically viable and allow people in all economic classes to get healthcare.

  3. […] via Stupid Idea For Readers To Destroy — The Inverse Square Blog […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: