Next Up: Who Gets To Wear The Yellow Stars Today?

Not to (a) step on the contemplation of Obama’s awesomely clear nailing of the GOP to their current platform: we-hate-America/lets-let-the-Chinese-eat-our-lunch, nor (b) to trespass on Dennis G.’s turf too much, but this, via TPM is in its way even more astounding than the Charleston objectively pro-treason story we enjoyed earlier in the day:

A fourth grade teacher in Norfolk, Virginia is in trouble for getting a bit too real in a lesson on the Civil War, in which she held a mock auction of black students while letting the white students bid on them.

On April 1st, Jessica Boyle separated students in her class and put the black and mixed race students up for sale, according to WVEC News, apparently in a well intentioned, but ill-advised attempt to demonstrate the injustices of the slave era.

Oscar Brown singing “Bid ’em In”

“Ill-advised” is as nuanced a way to describe this as I can imagine.  I’m even prepared to accept it.

But it’s funny.  I’ve been off the ‘tubes for the last few days as I help my students work on their documentary shorts.  This year their films are focused on research into conflict resolution.  One common feature of group conflict is that one side tends to have more power than others.  One thing the people we’re talking to about this research have observed with considerable rigor is that those more powerful folks tend to see the moral world differently — not just from a different point of view, but with different judgment — than do those out of power.

Which is to say that I find it wholly believable that Ms. Boyle meant well…and wholly tragic as well.

Or to put it another way:  on the 150th anniversary of Confederate treason in defense of their right to own human beings of African descent, this race thing ain’t over over here.

Update: I realize from the comments at the cross post over at Balloon Juice that my that my line about differences in power producing differences in moral perspective/judgment may not have been that clear.  That line was shorthand for this question:   how it could be possible to genuinely possess good intent and yet produce behavior that to a neutral party — someone not a member of a group in conflict — seems obviously malign, harmful.  In that context, the fact that some teacher could (perhaps) genuinely see this role-play as OK is a measure of just how far we have to go in dealing with issues of race and history in this country.

Image:  J. W. M. Turner, Slavers throwing overboard the Dead and Dying — Typhoon coming on, 1840.


Explore posts in the same categories: bad ideas, Race, Stupidity, Who thought that was a good idea?

Tags: ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

One Comment on “Next Up: Who Gets To Wear The Yellow Stars Today?”

  1. Andrew Curry Says:

    When I was younger there used to be a role playing learning game called Starpower in which kids were randomly divided into three groups, and the different groups got different entitlements to power. Group 1 could make rules, Group 2 could veto (some) rules, Group 3 just had to take what they were given. It used to produce similar results over two or three sessions – but obviously without the racial overtone. And produced some good discussions about why some people got to exercise power and others didn’t.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: